TotallyEffed said: "I struggled with the parts about the aunt, the mailbox/show choir subplot, and whatever happened in the town they lived in before. I found the parents to be too broad and cartoony. They said and did things that were so cruel they were unforgivable. I wanted the show to focus more on Kimberly, who was so intriguing and heartbreaking to me. I was way more interested in her journey and her relationship with Seth. I felt all the other stuff was underdeveloped, farfetched, and ultimately uninteresting. Victoria Clark was fabulous…joyful, silly, awkward, intelligent, and very sweet. Her story left me leaving the theatre so sad inside. I really felt for her."
Beware. Unpopular opinion below.
I found the parents so over-the-top awful and stupid that it took me completely out of the show. I hated them, and then we'd learn more, and it would get even more stupid and/or cruel. I was ready for Kimberly to borrow from the musical revival I'd seen the previous night and sing, "Epiphany" before doing something deserving to them with Debra's chemicals.
Show choir kids? Didn't care, and Debra's joke about them was revealing because, while a funny line and delivery by Bonnie Milligan, it also pretty much dismissed them from the show.
I've never been to a show where the audience repeatedly said, "Awww," after some dopey teenager says an insensitive thing to Kimberly (excusable, although only Seth is really her friend) or her parents do yet another terrible thing (not excusable, especially by the end). Kimberly's plight could have been compelling and felt genuine. Instead, the show seemed to be making the same treacly plea for sympathy for her that Kimberly - as played by Victoria Clark - didn't really seem to want for herself. Bookwriter David Lindsay-Abaire basically got her a treehouse.
Updated On: 3/18/23 at 07:04 PM