I caught a late preview performance of The Lost Boys this afternoon, and found the entire affair to be a ghastly mess from top to bottom.
There are glaring issues across the board, starting with the book and score, both of which are shockingly awful. The music leans heavily into a generic, Christian rock sound, while the lyrics are often outright laughable. Much of the dialogue is trite and corny beyond belief. Tonally, the show is all over the place. The first act is dark and moody, and the second act leans into over the top camp.
The cast does what they can, but there is only so much they can do with material this thin. Shoshana Bean and Paul Nolan get the worst of the brunt. The Frog Brothers come across as extremely grating rather than amusing, and Sam’s superhero number feels like something that should have been cut after the first workshop.
There is certainly no shortage of spectacle. However, despite the scale of the set and design, I found it surprisingly lacking in visual appeal. The flying sequences are cool, but we have seen the same thing done (and done better) with Peter Pan and Spider-Man. The final “fight sequence” is rather anticlimactic.
I went in genuinely excited for this as I’m always up for a big, spectacle-driven musical, but this was a colossal disappointment. Easily one of the worst new Broadway musicals I’ve seen in recent memory.
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "