Have we ever read such unanimously negative reviews on this site for a new show in previews? It seems the tone of the show is the problem - not satiric like Legally Blonde, not tragedy like Gypsy, not a character study like Company, not a social commentary like Chicago. Maybe the off-Broadway revival of Baker's Wife might be Stephen's high point this season, certainly a wonderful romantic musical score. Broadway just cannot have more of these 30 million dollar busts. A lot of the touring shows, the movies made into generic musicals, are not doing well at the box office on the road for a similar reason: no point of view, no particular theme, no reason to be a musical. Even flawed shows like Love Life, Tree Grows in Brooklyn, Tenderloin, or more recently Newsies and Scottsboro Boys had had a reason to be a musical and style. In those shows the musical score amplified characters, the theme, the style, or the world of the play even if the book might have been flawed.
I hope they can use the comments and the preview period to discover the key to the point of view and theme. Broadway needs a new musical hit this season since so few new shows are opening.