Sauja said: "Truly bananas that Mantello would be able to stage three new Broadway productions in the same season. I happen to think he's one of our best directors (I know opinion is divided on that front), but...literally, how would he even have the time?"
It's doable, but a feat of careful scheduling that requires great associate directors, SMs, and GMs. And it helps that all 3 have the same producer.
There are many examples of it working out just fine. Michael Greif had 3 openings in 3.5 months in 2024 (Days of Wine & Roses, Notebook, Hell's Kitch), Scott Ellis had 2 Broadway musicals in the spring of 2019 (TOOTSIE and KISS ME KATE) and three shows in 2014-15 (You Can't Take It With You, Elephant Man, On the 20th Century).
What makes this one tricky is that Downstate opens late in the fall season (Nov 15), and SMS starts previews early in the spring season (Feb 18 prev, Mar 18 opening). So the Metcalf play probably needs to start perfs in December or January, or it needs to open at the end of April and have a quicker rehearsal/preview process. And it goes without saying that Metcalf without an equal-or-greater costar is not a great box office bet.