I saw Matt Doyle go on as Melchior for both shows on his first day doing it ever. He was incredible--in a lot of ways I preferred him to Groff though he is amazing too.
for some reason..i can't imagine anyone else as melchoir and wendla..i'll have to see new people in the role..to me..lea michele and johnathon groff are the best..
I've seen both Matt and Jesse go on for Melchior and both were fantastic. Matt's probably the strongest Melchior - his voice is absolutely amazing and his acting is out of this world.
I also saw Gerard Canonico go on for Moritz and he was incredible. The boy is brilliant in every role he goes on for. He's probably the strongest cast member in the show.
I've seen Phoebe as Wendla twice. While I enjoyed her performance, I think I still prefer Lea Michele. Phoebe did deliver some lines differently than Lea, which was nice and new. Her voice however is a bit weak.
I saw Jen Damiano as Ilse and she was unbelivable. It was her first time going on in the role and went I talked to JGJ he told me he couldnt believe how amazing she is. I love her portrayal and she is just so nice. And i concur that Gerard singing touch me is amazing!
<------ Me and my friends with patti Lupone at my friends afterparty for her concert with audra mcdonald during the summer of 2007.
"I am sorry but it is an unjust world and virtue is only triumphant in theatricle performances" The Mikado
I've seen Matt Doyle as Melchior and I think he is better than Groff. I saw Phoebe's Ilse and her voice was weak. I saw Jesse as Georg and it was awful. I can't believe that he would be good as Melchior. I saw Gerard and Georg and it blew me away.
I've seen Eryn Murman go on as Ilse and she is my favorite Ilse. The way she captures the character is unbelievable! Alexandra Socha and I were talking about Eryn's portrayal of Ilse and how incredible she is.
Speaking of Alexandra Socha, I've seen her understudy Wendla. She has a voice that is definitely more raw than Lea's and she has a younger feel to the character, in my opinion. I'm dieing to see Phoebe as Wendla.
"Speaking of Alexandra Socha, I've seen her understudy Wendla. She has a voice that is definitely more raw than Lea's and she has a younger feel to the character, in my opinion."
I agree. That's what I really liked about her.
I really want to see Matt Doyle go on as Melchior now, after reading all of these positive comments.
guyes look at this thread..it talks about matt doyle going on for groff for the first time july 14th..
if i recall wasn't Johnathon B. Wright an understudy for Melchoir in the beginning?.
i just checked my playbill from the end of december and he is not listed as a melchoir understudy..ONLY Jesse and Matt asre listed
Updated On: 1/23/08 at 09:04 PM
jesse swenson as melchior...he was okay in my opinion.
matt doyle as otto, ernst, and hanschen. he's just amazing. i got a kick out of how I saw him play ernst and then the next time I saw it he was hanschen >.< great voice and stuff. after seeing him do all these roles I would love to see him as melchior, always hearing good things about him in that role.
eryn murman as ana and ilse...can't really remember her as ana but she was a good ilse.
drew tyler bell as hanschen. he was good, but i like johnny b. wright more.
There was a day where all the male swings were on...but all I remember is that matt doyle was otto >.<
I'd like to see gerard as moritz and socha as wendla since i'm always hearing good things about that...
Drew Tyler Bell as Hanschen, his acting was great, but I thought his singing was ok.
Eryn as Anna...I love her voice!
Brian Charles Johnson as Moritz....um...I know a lot of people liked him, but I was so dissapointed. Don't Do Sadness was such a let down....I felt like all of his emotion was in his right hand because he kept shaking it the whole time. Don't get me wrong he was great for going on for the first time, but hes no Moritz for me.
Jesse as Georg...again I know people didnt like him but I thought he was really good. I really want to see him as Melchior!