This one had more than just a few bars of music "borrowed" :
"Be a Clown" is a song written by Cole Porter for the 1948 film The Pirate. The song was first performed by Judy Garland and Gene Kelly in the film The Pirate.
The song was featured in an episode of Land of the Giants and also in the 2004 film De-Lovely.
The song "Make 'Em Laugh" (by Nacio Herb Brown and Arthur Freed) in the film Singin' in the Rain was largely plagiarized from "Be a Clown"[1] although Cole Porter did not make a complaint. Both films were MGM productions.
2016 These Paper Bullets (1/02) Our Mother's Brief Affair (1/06), Dragon Boat Racing (1/08), Howard - reading (1/28), Shear Madness (2/10), Fun Home (2/17), Women Without Men (2/18), Trip Of Love (2/21), The First Gentleman -reading (2/22), Southern Comfort (2/23), The Robber Bridegroom (2/24), She Loves Me (3/11), Shuffle Along (4/12), Shear Madness (4/14), Dear Evan Hansen (4/16), American Psycho (4/23), Tuck Everlasting (5/10), Indian Summer (5/15), Peer Gynt (5/18), Broadway's Rising Stars (7/11), Trip of Love (7/27), CATS (7/31), The Layover (8/17), An Act Of God (8/31), The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time (8/24), Heisenberg (10/12), Fiddler On The Roof (11/02), Othello (11/23), Dear Evan Hansen (11/26), Les Liaisons Dangereuses (12/21) 2017 In Transit (2/01), Groundhog Day (4/04), Ring Twice For Miranda (4/07), Church And State (4/10), The Lucky One (4/19), Ernest Shackleton Loves Me (5/16), Building The Wall (5/19), Indecent (6/01), Six Degrees of Separation (6/09), Marvin's Room (6/28), A Doll's House Pt 2 (7/25) Curvy Widow (8/01)
"You can't have it both ways, pal. They are the exact same six notes - if you want to play they are different rhythmically, then all the other examples cited here go in the toilet. Memory is NOTHING like Bolero in feel, tempo, or rhythm, and yet apparently it's okay to cite that ridiculous example, right?"
Except that I didn't cite that example. Pal.
A "note", as I believe you know, is made up of many qualities, most importantly pitch and duration. I really don't have a horse in this race, but it seems to me a string of six pitches that happen to be identical from one song to the next aren't enough to justify a charge of "plagiarism". Admittedly, those six pitches also have in common that they are a discrete phrase at the very beginning of the song. But I think it's important that they don't "do" the same thing from one song to the next. Whereas the Webber/Puccini phrase that inspired this thread DOES "do" the same thing in both instances, even though there may be rhythmic differences there as well.
However plagiarism cases are decided, it's clearly a highly subjective matter.
There is a difference between "winking" at an audience with a blatantly interpolated classic or pop melody as a stunt or cameo, on the one hand, and inentional plagiarism or unintentional usurpation, intended to impress the audience (or at least some of them) as an original creation, on the other. Its challenging - though not impossible - to argue that Webber's borrowing from La Fanciulla, is a "wink" at the audience. In contrast, Sondheim, the great puzzlemeister, was obviously engaged in a "wink."
This is not the only occasion where Webber was highly influenced, to put it mildly, by Puccini.
OK, now I'm going to be accused of being a Webber-hater. I assure you I'm not. Nor do I really have any problem with plagiarism in moderation, in any form. As long as the source is well known such as the "borrowing" is evident.
I don't know if the courts would support a "winking" theory, or if they give passes to celebrities whose "obvious" intentions are a "wink," whether they're good at puzzles or not.
Some of the strangest posts here. Seriously.
Oh ... and WEBBER HATER!!! There, feel better?
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
This is not the only occasion where Webber was highly influenced, to put it mildly, by Puccini.
I read something about his Requiem being tied to Puccini, but I couldn't find anything specific. But that's the only other instance I've heard about. No doubt, people will find a way to put some of his notes together and accuse him of whatever. When we get to the point of accusing him of ripping off the I-IV-V-I chord progression at the end of any given song, let me know. I really want to see how that pans out.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
best 12, the courts' wouldn't care as long as the "wink" was to something in the "public domain," and my analysis was in response to those whose concerns were not about the legal ("public domain") versus the ethical.
And who knew it was written in 1914? John Williams starts his compositions early, way before production begins. Before his own birth, actually. Now that's a man who plans ahead.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
See, that's what I said, but this guy insisted the chorus was simply a different verse. He tried to school me on music theory and claimed the song has no chorus. I didn't care because I have the LP personally autographed by Jerry Bock to me containing an inside joke regarding the new musical he composed that we were working on. So suck it, music theory dude.
And I love The Planets by John Williams! I always thought it would make an excellent subject for a Fantasia-esque Disney animated film along with Hans Zimmer's Pictures at an Exhibition.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
It was initially planned for Fantasia, but they scrapped the idea. It came up again for Fantasia 2000 and was scrapped again.
That's awesome about Jerry Bock! Very cool.
Hey, maybe your friend saw a really low-budget production of Fiddler where they hired no chorus members. If that were the case, "Sunrise, Sunset" would have no chorus.
Otherwise, musically, yes, it does.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
I can't imagine scrapping The Planets. The music is so expressive and vivid and the opportunity for capturing it with visuals is so ripe with creativity. Not to mention pairing it with some info not only on the planets themselves, but the Roman gods for which the planets (and the musical movements) were named. It's an educational two-fer.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
Since the first Fantasia already had planets (the Rite of Spring) and mythical gods (Beethoven's Sixth), they probably didn't need it.
For the second one, who knows? It didn't make the final cut. It was probably voted out by viewers. Maybe it couldn't handle the country medley or it riffed too much.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22